spacer
 
 
21
OCT
spacer   Method used determines which evolution story is told
Posted by O'Leary at 10:55 AM
 
Genetic sequence comparisons are often used to try to establish relationships in evolution. But as Robert Deyes, writing over at Access Research Network, shows, the molecular "clock" often conflicts with the "tree of life.":
Writing over a decade ago, UCLA biologists Laura Maley and Charles Marshall noted how genetic sequence comparisons carried out between different animal phyletic groups can lead to significantly different interpretations of evolutionary relationships depending on which species is chosen to represent each group (Ref 1). Such a finding should raise concern amongst protagonists of molecular systematics who today use sequence data to determine evolutionary relationships. Yale University's Gavin Naylor showed just how inaccurate such comparisons could be in the context of the vertebrate evolutionary tree (Ref 2). Mitochondrial DNA sequence analyses of 19 different taxa generated an astounding result- frogs and fish were clustered in the same clade as chickens even though "strong morphological and fossil evidence" did not show these as being in any way related by a common ancestor (Ref 2). The same mitochondrial DNA sequences placed echinoderms- which include starfish and sea urchins- in closer proximity to the vertebrates than amphioxus even though, being a chordate, we would expect amphioxus to be closer (Ref 2). That is, if we give the evolutionary tree any credibility. Given such anomalies, one should be cautious about stating what we really do know about the evolutionary relationships between different classes of vertebrates. Nevertheless molecular biologist Thomas Sakmar and his colleagues from the Rockefeller University seemingly threw caution to the wind several years later when they redesigned the rhodopsin molecule- a visual, light perceiving pigment that is ubiquitous throughout nature (Ref 3).

Also just up at The Post-Darwinist, Denyse O'Leary's news and culture blog on the intelligent design controversy:

Expelled DVD released today, to brisk sales, more hit reviews

Great offer! Get Ben Stein's Expelled - plus new book and earlier ID films

 
  Add Comment   |   Email this Blog
 

No response for this post

   
button recent post Recent Post
arrowIntelligent design and popular culture: Computers vs. Darwinism? A computer teacher comments
arrowThe universe has the hallmarks of design: And what can anyone do about it?
arrowHorrid doubt file: Reasons to think your mind is real
arrowFarewell, fat gene ... goodbye gay gene ... so long, sloppiness gene ...
arrowStraws in the wind: Atheists and agnostics support constructive debate on design
Archives
 
arrowDecember 2008 (1)
arrowNovember 2008 (5)
arrowOctober 2008 (8)
arrowSeptember 2008 (13)
arrowAugust 2008 (2)
arrowJuly 2008 (8)
arrowJune 2008 (3)
arrowMay 2008 (20)
arrowApril 2008 (5)
arrowMarch 2008 (6)
arrowFebruary 2008 (10)
arrowJanuary 2008 (7)
arrowDecember 2007 (10)
 
 
spacer